Why I Love Both Catholic AND Public Education


When I contemplated parenthood, certain things were never a question. For instance: I knew my kids would go to Catholic school. To be honest, having grown up in Catholic grade school and worked in a Catholic grade school, as well as subbing in the public schools, I was a little snotty about it. The Catholic school community prides itself on higher academic standards and better behaved kids, and I was all over that. Insufferably so, I’m afraid.

Then Julianna came along, and we found ourselves immersed in public education. As she begins the second grade, she is in her seventh year in the public schools. And it has been eye-opening. We spent a year in conversation with the public and the Catholic school, trying to determine if Julianna could attend. By the time that process was over, I was relieved to be told the Catholic school couldn’t serve her, because I was already such a fan of her public school.

So we are in an unusual position: kids in Catholic school, a child in public school gifted program, a kid in special ed in the public schools, and now a kid serving as a “peer model” in the early childhood special ed program. We’ve got the spectrum pretty well covered.

So I thought I’d start this new school year by sharing why I love BOTH Catholic AND public education.

Image by gordontour, via Flickr

I love Catholic education because it’s Catholic. I love the fact that Christ is central to the school’s mission, that conflict resolution and behavior can be approached through the lens of faith and the dignity due to all people as children of God. I love that my boys get to learn in an environment where faith can be integrated into all areas of life and knowledge. In theory, at least, they are being formed without the false dichotomy that makes so many people view faith and reason as fundamentally at odds.

If the academic work is at a higher level, well, that’s icing on the cake, but it’s not the reason the school exists, and it’s certainly not why I send my kids there.


Image via Pixabay

I love public education because of its inclusivity. I do not doubt that there are kids at Julianna’s school whose families have made life choices deeply at odds with what we believe. It’s all but certain that as she gets older, she will be exposed to behaviors and attitudes we will find tremendously problematic.

But that’s not all bad. I am grateful that I went to public high school, where I was smacked in the face with things that challenged my insular view of the world…before I left home and the support network of my strong-in-faith parents. There’s a danger in insulating ourselves from people who see the world differently than we do. It’s hard to empathize with vastly different life experiences if all we ever hear from the people we hang around with is an echo of our own outlook on the world. It’s harder to recognize the validity of experiences that are different from our own. Harder to escape slipping into an attitude of exclusivity.

I love public education because Julianna has the chance to interact with kids of different races—lots of kids. Lots of different races. Her schoolmates, unlike those at the Catholic school, have the chance to actually interact on a meaningful level with kids with disabilities of all kinds, and break down some of those barriers.

I love public education because I’ve seen the heroic efforts made by the teachers, the genuine care they have for their students, some of whom are coming to school without proper breakfast or rest or even a secure home. I’ve seen the way Julianna’s school administrators work together to encourage families to get involved and to build community.

For all the criticism surrounding it, public education is a monumental accomplishment. The fact that they can do so much with the challenges they face? Pretty amazing, if you ask me.

So yes, I send my boys to Catholic school. But I am thrilled beyond what I can share with the experience my daughter has had in the public school system. And today I wanted to take the time to say so.

2 thoughts on “Why I Love Both Catholic AND Public Education

  1. Wonderful post. For all the bad things you can say about public schools, no matter where you live, the reality is that most of them are staffed by at least some people who deeply care about all children–not just the “nice” ones, and that the schools themselves, as a whole, do a a good job with kids across the economic and ability spectrums. For all the good you can say about Catholic schools, there are few if any today that make any pretense of being for any kids other than those whose parents can afford substantial tuition and who are able to meet certain academic standards.

    As a parent who has her youngest in a Catholic school, and who, like you, likes the integration of faith into life, I get SO annoyed when the principal starts talking about how much better we are than the public school down the street–not because of faith but because of academics or behavior–when I know that just isn’t the case. The kids down the street are poorer and their skin color is often darker, but making the gate to the schoolyard more narrow does not make a school better.

    • Thanks! I’ve been mulling over this topic for a couple of weeks, and there’s so much more to say–but this is a good start.

      On Wed, Aug 19, 2015 at 11:54 AM, Kathleen M. Basi wrote:


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.